Assessing Fixed Income in Target Retirement Strategies
The trend toward index-based target date funds has not only continued but actually accelerated in recent years, as plan sponsors continue to value transparency, low-costs and strong long-term results. The market has generally accepted the key principles behind an index-based approach; asset allocation is the most important decision, broad diversification improves outcomes, and cost savings compound over time.
While index-based implementation comes in many shapes and sizes, and asset allocation decisions are not “passive,” this approach still has its detractors. Two common critiques of index-based target date funds (TDFs) still come up frequently:
1. The strategy relies on issuance-weighted benchmarks to manage fixed income
2. “Passive” approaches lack the requisite flexibility to protect participant wealth in market downturns
Here we will counter the critics, particularly in the context of volatile market cycles.
June 26, 2020
In our full whitepaper, Beyond the Benchmark: Assessing Fixed Income in Target Retirement Strategies, we compared State Street’s fixed income approach to that of a prominent active target-date manager, using data going back to 2005. While we did not contest the idea that an active approach to fixed income can result in outperformance over commonly used fixed income benchmarks, we did raise question the costs, particularly to diversification, of overperformance.
Importantly, how did outperformance impact the experience of the investor in the target date fund, and how does diversification play a role in mitigating key risks?
We found that the excess return of individual active fixed income funds has typically been delivered via credit over weights, and subsequently higher correlations to equities. The fixed income allocation from the active target date manager had performed well in risk-on and growth-oriented markets, and it had modestly outperformed the State Street fixed income allocation over the time period analyzed. However, the active approach lagged significantly in negative equity markets, when participants value the diversification that fixed income is expected to provide.
While Q1 2020 presented a difficult environment for markets and the participants that rely on them for retirement savings, it also served as an opportunity to reexamine the performance of these approaches in a period of heightened market volatility. During March, as equity markets were rapidly selling off, fixed income markets were pressured due to liquidity being tested, and transaction costs were significantly elevated.
It was in this market context that we conducted our analysis by taking the five largest active target retirement strategies by assets under management and comparing the normalized monthly returns from each fixed income portfolio to the State Street fixed income allocation in both a longer-dated (far from retirement) and income fund (in retirement). We made this comparison by aggregating the performance of the fixed income components in the glidepath at these two stages.
While target date strategies differ in their objectives, generally glidepaths feature equity-heavy portfolios in the longer-dated vintages (the median glidepath holds 90% in equities for younger investors) and more balanced risk approaches in the income funds. The allocations of the income vintages vary depending on whether the glidepath is “to” or “through” retirement, but our analysis included both approaches.
State Street Fixed Income Return
Average Active Fixed Income Return
Source: State Street Global Advisors. Morningstar Direct as of March 31, 2020. Active managers chosen were the five largest actively managed Target Retirement strategies by AUM per P&I as of 12/31/18. Fixed Income return is calculated by weighting each underlying fund return by its normalized allocation in each respective vintage as of the beginning of each month.
In longer-dated vintages dominated by equity risk, outperformance from fixed income in down markets is key. During Q1, the majority of active strategies failed in this regard.
Most notably, the State Street fixed income allocation outperformed the average active manager by 925 basis points for the month of March.
SSGA Fixed Income Return
Average Active Fixed Income Return
Source: State Street Global Advisors. Morningstar Direct as of March 31, 2020. Active managers chosen were the five largest actively managed Target Retirement strategies by AUM per P&I as of 12/31/18. Fixed Income return is calculated by weighting the monthly performance of each underlying fixed income fund in the listed vintage by its percentage of the overall fixed income allocation, using allocations at the start of each month.
Income funds can be more difficult to compare, as each manager lands at a very different point on the glidepath. Objectives for retirees are more complicated, needing to balance wealth preservation with inflation management and the need to combat the risk of running out of money in retirement. As such, fixed income allocations must balance downside protection with generating sufficient return from a bond-heavy portfolio. Still, in Q1 we found that the State Street fixed income allocation outperformed its active peers by an average of 228 basis points during March.
Using Q1 2020 as the most recent example of a negative equity market, we saw State Street’s approach to fixed income continue to outperform the average active manager. Importantly, while the State Street fixed income exposures are index-based, using more granular building blocks rather than relying on a single fixed income exposure to US Aggregate bonds allows for more appropriate risk and return characteristics for participants at each step of their careers. This led to smaller drawdowns relative to their active peers in the income fund, and substantial outperformance relative to those active peers in equity-heavy longer-dated vintages.
In our business, diversification is synonymous with preparedness. Recent global events have enforced the value of anticipation and shown that a thoughtful index manager won’t be caught flat-footed.
The views expressed in this material are the views of SSGA Defined Contribution as at 12 June 2020, and are subject to change based on market and other conditions.
This document contains certain statements that may be deemed forward looking statements. Please note that any such statements are not guarantees of any future performance, and actual results or developments may differ materially from those projected.
The information provided does not constitute investment advice and it should not be relied on as such. It should not be considered a solicitation to buy or an offer to sell a security. It does not take into account any investor’s particular investment objectives, strategies, tax status or investment horizon. Investing involves risk, including the risk of loss of principal. The whole or any part of this work may not be reproduced, copied or transmitted or any of its contents disclosed to third parties without SSGA’s express written consent.
Diversification does not ensure a profit or guarantee against loss.
Equity securities may fluctuate in value in response to the activities of individual companies and general market and economic conditions.
Bonds generally present less short-term risk and volatility than stocks, but contain interest rate risk (as interest rates raise, bond prices usually fall); issuer default risk; issuer credit risk; liquidity risk; and inflation risk. These effects are usually pronounced for longer-term securities. Any fixed income security sold or redeemed prior to maturity may be subject to a substantial gain or loss.
State Street Global Advisors Target Date Fund are designed for investors expecting to retire around the year indicated in each fund’s name. When choosing a Fund, investors should consider whether they anticipate retiring significantly earlier or later than age 65 even if such investors retire on or near a fund’s approximate target date. There may be other considerations relevant to fund selection and investors should select the fund that best meets their individual circumstances and investment goals. The funds' asset allocation strategy becomes increasingly conservative as it approaches the target date and beyond. The investment risks of each Fund change over time as its asset allocation changes.
Assumptions and forecasts used by State Street Global Advisors in developing the Portfolio’s asset allocation glide path may not be in line with future capital market returns and participant savings activities, which could result in losses near, at or after the target date year or could result in the Portfolio not providing adequate income at and through retirement.
Benchmark returns are unmanaged and do not reflect the deduction of any fees or expenses. Benchmark returns reflect all items of income, gain and loss and the reinvestment of dividends and other income as applicable.
All the index performance results referred to are provided exclusively for comparison purposes only. It should not be assumed that they represent the performance of any particular investment.
Before investing, consider the funds' investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses. To obtain a prospectus or summary prospectus which contains this and other information, call 1-800-997-7327, download a prospectus or summary prospectus now, or talk to your financial advisor. Read it carefully before investing.
Distributor: State Street Global Advisors Funds Distributors, LLC, member FINRA, SIPC, an indirect wholly owned subsidiary of State Street Corporation. References to State Street may include State Street Corporation and its affiliates. Certain State Street affiliates provide services and receive fees from the SSGA Funds.
THIS SITE IS INTENDED FOR U.S. INVESTORS ONLY.
No Offer/Local Restrictions
Nothing contained in or on the Site should be construed as a solicitation of an offer to buy or offer, or recommendation, to acquire or dispose of any security, commodity, investment or to engage in any other transaction. SSGA Intermediary Business offers a number of products and services designed specifically for various categories of investors. Not all products will be available to all investors. The information provided on the Site is not intended for distribution to, or use by, any person or entity in any jurisdiction or country where such distribution or use would be contrary to law or regulation.
All persons and entities accessing the Site do so on their own initiative and are responsible for compliance with applicable local laws and regulations. The Site is not directed to any person in any jurisdiction where the publication or availability of the Site is prohibited, by reason of that person's nationality, residence or otherwise. Persons under these restrictions must not access the Site.
Information for Non-U.S. Investors:
The products and services described on this web site are intended to be made available only to persons in the United States, and the information on this web site is only for such persons. Nothing on this web site shall be considered a solicitation to buy or an offer to sell a security to any person in any jurisdiction where such offer, solicitation, purchase or sale would be unlawful under the securities laws of such jurisdiction.