Skip to main content
Insights

Agentic commerce: A new era for consumer sectors

9 min read

Mariola Pokorska, CFA
Sector Research Strategist

David Huang
Senior Sector Research Strategist

Jeff Looby
Equity Research Analyst

Imagine an AI assistant that knows when you need to restock household essentials, finds a gift that fits your budget, and plans your vacations, all without cluttering your browsing history. Agentic commerce is introducing a more personalized, proactive, and effortless way for online consumers to shop for products and services, including AI-powered personal agents—like Meta's Muse—that can help consumers compare product options, prices, and potentially complete purchases on their behalf.

While agentic commerce is unlikely to increase demand or make consumers spend substantially more, it could change where their money goes—and which companies capture the profits. For investors in Consumer Discretionary and Consumer Staples sectors, the implications go beyond convenience to include shifting market share, altering pricing power, and providing opportunities to improve—or pressure—profit margins for retailers.

To explore these broader investment implications, we spoke with Jeff Looby from State Street’s Active Fundamental Equity team about how the emerging trends could reshape retail competition across consumer sectors, where the near-term risks and opportunities may materialize, and what factors could influence the pace of adoption.

AI-enhanced shopping: Changing the customer experience

E-commerce companies have used traditional AI for many years to optimize keyword search algorithms and product display pages. More recently, new AI chatbots like ChatGPT have allowed customers to use natural language to describe what they are looking for, enabling even more robust recommendations. The latest innovation of agentic AI increasingly recommends, compares, and eventually completes purchases on a consumer’s behalf to transform online shopping into a bespoke and highly customized experience.

By processing vast amounts of information including product descriptions, customer reviews, pricing, availability, and purchase histories, AI agents can turn a long list of options into a personalized shortlist of products best aligned with an individual's preferences and needs. This can personalize the shopping experience while reducing the time consumers spend researching purchases.

Demand and market share redistribution

AI-driven discovery will make it easier for consumers to compare products and services across a wider range of merchants, which may help reduce search costs for consumers, but it also will increase price transparency and competitive pressures across businesses. As AI assistants become more capable, this may influence not only what consumers buy, but also where and when they buy it.

A key investment question is whether AI-driven discovery creates new demand or simply redirects existing spending. Early company results are encouraging but not conclusive. While Walmart has reported higher average order values among users of its Sparky AI assistant,1 and Amazon has highlighted increased engagement and spending among customers interacting with AI-powered shopping tools,2 it remains unclear whether AI itself drives extra spending or whether customers making larger, research-intensive purchases are simply more likely to use these tools.

Although personalized recommendations may generate some incremental purchases, we believe the more likely near-term impact is a redistribution of spending rather than a meaningful increase in overall consumption. Consumers may not buy significantly more toothpaste, electronics, or groceries just because of AI. Instead, they may shift spending toward retailers offering lower prices, faster delivery, or products better suited to their needs. For investors, that makes customer acquisition, conversion, basket size, and market share momentum more relevant than assumptions of broad demand creation.

Profit pool shifts: Who controls the customer relationship?

As AI agents gain influence over discovery and recommendations, the key question becomes who owns the customer interface—and therefore the economics surrounding acquisition, advertising, pricing, and loyalty—and who captures the profits?

General purpose or “horizontal” agents can learn preferences and compare products across multiple retailers. “Vertical” commerce platforms retain supplier relationships, inventory, fulfillment networks, payments, customer service operations, memberships, and proprietary purchase data. Both control valuable parts of the transaction, and neither appears likely to replace the other entirely.

AI-led discovery could broaden access for smaller retailers that historically lacked the scale or marketing budget of larger competitors, potentially reducing their reliance on paid search and marketplace advertising. At the same time, easier comparison and greater price transparency could intensify competition and reward companies with differentiated products, stronger value propositions, and dependable service models.

The eventual balance of power will shape industry profit pools, but the economic value captured by each participant remains uncertain. AI platforms may gain influence over discovery and advertising economics, while retailers continue to control fulfillment and service. But for investors it will be important to watch whether bargaining power shifts toward the interface that recommends the product or whether it remains with the businesses that source, deliver, and support it.

Improving retail operations: Efficiency versus profitability

Some of AI's most immediate impact may come from improving retailers' operations rather than driving new revenues.

Retailers have long used data analytics to forecast demand and optimize product assortments. Newer AI tools expand these capabilities by processing larger datasets, incorporating more variables, and improving decision-making speed. Better demand forecasting can help retailers reduce stockouts and markdowns, improve inventory turns and working capital, and speed up delivery, particularly for seasonal and perishable products. In e-commerce, where availability and delivery speed influence purchases, this can also help retailers capture sales.

Robotics and automation can further improve fulfillment speed and labor efficiency, but adoption remains limited: only about 25% of warehouses worldwide implement some form of automation and only 10% utilize advanced technologies.3 High upfront costs favor large retailers with the scale to invest in these systems. Unlike widely available AI software, fulfillment automation may be harder for small competitors to replicate quickly, potentially strengthening larger retailers’ competitive advantage.

AI could also improve operational efficiency in labor-intensive industries such as hospitality and restaurants. Airbnb reported that its AI assistant resolved nearly 45% of customer issues initiated through the tool without human intervention, while customer support costs per booking declined approximately 16% year-over-year in Q2 2026, partly reflecting AI improvements.4 McDonald’s reported over 90% accuracy for its AI-powered drive-thru ordering tool and expects it to save at least 50 labor hours per week as deployment scales.5

However, we believe intense competition means much of the benefit is likely to be reinvested in pricing and customer experience, or passed on to consumers, rather than retained as lasting margin improvement. Retail remains one of the most competitive industries globally, and many retailers compete primarily on value.

Different implications across US consumer sectors

For investors, the rise of AI-driven commerce could create broad opportunities across the consumer sectors, though the investment implications are likely to differ across Consumer Discretionary and Consumer Staples companies. Greater efficiency and convenience may create opportunities, but they will not benefit every business equally.

Consumer Discretionary: Discovery, differentiation, and fulfillment

The greatest disruption may occur in higher-value, infrequent, and research-intensive categories with many competing products and channels. Agentic AI is well suited to helping consumers navigate complex purchase decisions, making product visibility, price, delivery, and service increasingly important.

Potential beneficiaries could include scaled retailers, differentiated brands, travel platforms, home improvement companies, and businesses with strong fulfillment networks or proprietary customer data. More exposed companies may include undifferentiated merchants that rely heavily on paid discovery or sell products that agents can easily substitute.

Consumer Staples: Habit, value, and substitution

Consumer Staples companies may experience a different dynamic. Recurring demand and established buying habits may limit behavioral change and how much AI expands consumption, but increased price transparency and automated replenishment and product substitution could change what enters the consumer’s basket. This may serve to reinforce incumbents with strong loyalty and distribution—or make substitution easier when an alternative offers better value or availability.

For Staples investors, price transparency may place greater pressure on weaker brands while increasing the value of trusted products, dependable availability, and broad distribution. The ability to remain the default choice—rather than merely one of many comparable options—could become an important competitive advantage.

Across both sectors: Retention, pricing power, earnings quality, and trust

Across both categories, what matters is how companies use AI to strengthen customer retention, enhance pricing power, and drive sustainable earnings growth. Large retailers with sophisticated fulfillment networks and the scale to invest in automation could gain market share, while less differentiated merchants may face greater pricing pressure. Among consumer brands, loyalty and product differentiation may become more valuable as AI makes price comparisons and product substitution easier.

Like the early days of e-commerce itself, agentic commerce is still in its formative stages. Trust and security will ultimately prove as important as technology in determining how quickly agentic commerce is adopted. Consumers may be comfortable using AI to research and compare products well before they are comfortable allowing it to make purchases independently. Broader adoption hinges on giving users confidence that agents understand their intention, can transact securely, and are capable of providing appropriate protections and outcomes when something goes wrong. As these safeguards develop, consumers may become more willing to delegate a greater portion of the shopping journey to AI.

Consumer sectors: Navigating disruption through cyclical opportunities and defensive resilience

Few innovations have transformed the way consumers purchase products and services as profoundly as e-commerce. Online shopping offers consumers broader selection, lower prices, and greater convenience, yet still accounts for just over 17% of total US retail sales.6 AI could now usher in the next wave of change. While e-commerce transformed where consumers shop, agentic commerce could change how they shop—helping consumers reduce search time, find better products and services, and derive greater value and price transparency from an increasingly intelligent retail ecosystem. For investors, that shift puts customer engagement and the evolving business model in focus.

The broader adoption of AI in commerce, including the emergence of AI agents, represents an exciting new chapter for investors in consumer sectors. AI could enhance customer engagement, unlock operating efficiencies, and expand the ways goods and services are bought and sold. For Consumer Discretionary and Staples investors, the investment question is not simply who adopts AI—but who turns it into stronger customer relationships and more efficient operations.

While questions remain around how the opportunities from agentic commerce will evolve, consumer sectors can offer investors exposure to this new wave of innovation across the business cycle, combining the cyclical growth opportunities of Consumer Discretionary with the defensive characteristics of Consumer Staples.

More on sector investing