Defined-benefit pension plans that implement a liability-driven investment (LDI) framework1 for their assets often face challenges on their way to a fully hedged portfolio. On the one hand, they must continue to seek returns in order to reach fully funded status; on the other, they’re under pressure to reduce liability-hedging risk. Recent research by State Street Global Advisors found that plans which are able to tolerate a degree of risk and have an interest in alpha generation (not just in drawdown mitigation) could benefit from benchmark-unconstrained defensive strategies, which carry a dual risk-and-return mandate.
Defensive Equity Strategies
Defensive equity strategies actively explore the market’s full opportunity set, constructing portfolios which seek to maximize return per unit of risk. Defensive strategies are built on empirical evidence that risk is not symmetrically rewarded in the market, and that a low-risk portfolio with an alpha-seeking component can create a compelling return stream while performing well in both up and down markets. Interestingly, our research found that drawdown profiles for a representative global defensive equity strategy were comparable to those for the MSCI World Minimum Volatility Index, despite the defensive strategy’s alpha-seeking component. This suggests that defensive equity strategies, like low volatility strategies, can help to protect against large drawdowns.
60/40 Portfolio (80% Funded)
Many pension plans in transition toward a fully hedged end state subscribe to a diversified 60% equity/40% fixed-income allocation for their portfolios. Most of that equity allocation is directed to market-capitalization weighted index exposures, which provide the potential for higher returns compared to fixed income. At the same time, these equity investments also expose the portfolio to capital-market risk.
For a hypothetical 60/40 portfolio2 with a funded ratio of around 80%, we calculated the effect of introducing a representative global defensive equity strategy.3 Our analysis of the reallocated portfolio shows a meaningful reduction in risk compared to the base-case portfolio. We found that overall portfolio risk was reduced by over 13%, while returns remained roughly the same, leading to an improvement in risk-adjusted returns of nearly 14%. Correlation to liabilities also improved substantially. Moreover, these results were achieved with a 1.45% reduction in risk contribution from equities.
60/40 Portfolio (De-risking)
We also calculated the effect of introducing a representative global defensive equity strategy into a de-risking portfolio that is nearing fully funded status and has moved its fixed-income portfolio to long credit in an attempt to hedge the liability risk.4 Adding the defensive equity strategy5 improves the set of outcomes for the pension plan as measured by risk-adjusted returns, total volatility, correlation to liabilities, and maximum drawdown over the examined period; it reduced the risk contribution from equities by 3.18%, resulting in a 12% improvement in the total risk of the portfolio, despite the increase in the risk contribution of fixed income. The inclusion of the defensive equity strategy resulted in an improvement of 6.5% in maximum drawdown over the examined time period and meaningfully improved the overall correlation of the portfolio to liabilities.
Based on our research, we firmly believe that equity risk can be a key contributor to future DB plan returns. Our analysis shows that plans could benefit from a close look at how efficiently they’re spending that risk to meet their return objectives. A focus on on risk-adjusted returns can help plans to maximize the benefits they realize from their equity exposures.
In sum, our research demonstrates that defensive equities can be a highly effective tool for DB plans as they seek to progress toward fully funded status and fully hedged liabilities. We believe they should be seriously considered as an important component of a broader LDI strategy.
1 A liability-driven investment (LDI) strategy strives to link the asset and liability sides of the investment balance sheet, rather than focusing exclusively on the asset side. An LDI strategy is particularly useful in situations – as in the case of defined-benefit plans – in which future liabilities can be predicted with reasonable accuracy.
2 Original 80%-funded portfolio exposures: S&P 500 35%; Russell 2000 5%; MSCI EAFE 15%; MSCI EM 5%; US Aggregate Bonds 35%; High Yield Bonds 5%.
3 Adjusted 80%-funded portfolio exposures: S&P 500 15%; Russell 2000 5%; MSCI EAFE 5%; representative defensive equity portfolio 30%; MSCI EM 5%; US Aggregate Bonds 35%; High Yield Bonds 5%.
4 Original De-risking portfolio exposures: S&P 500 35%; Russell 2000 5%; MSCI EAFE 15%; MSCI EM 5%; Long Credit 40%.
5 Adjusted De-risking portfolio exposures: S&P 500 15%; Russell 2000 5%; MSCI EAFE 5%; Representative defensive equity portfolio 30%; MSCI EM 5%; Long Credit 40%.
Defensive equities: While the term is generally used in connection with stocks that possess defensive characteristics, such as stable cash flows and lower volatility, it may also be used to refer to lower-risk securities such as government bonds and preferred shares. Defensive stocks may outperform their flashier counterparts like growth stocks during periods of economic uncertainty when equity markets display a declining trend, but will underperform during periods of economic expansion.
Funding ratio: A ratio of a pension or annuity's assets to its liabilities. A funding ratio above 1 indicates that the pension or annuity is able to cover all payments it is obligated to make.
Hedging: Hedging is an investment taken out to limit the risk of another investment, insurance is an example of a real-world hedge.
Liability Driven Investment: A liability-driven investment, otherwise known as liability-driven investing, is primarily slated toward gaining enough assets to cover all current and future liabilities. This type of investing is common when dealing with defined-benefit pension plans because the liabilities involved quite frequently climb into billions of dollars with the largest of the pension plans.
Low volatility investing: Low volatility investing means putting your money in stocks with lower price fluctuations.
The information provided does not constitute investment advice and it should not be relied on as such. It should not be considered a solicitation to buy or an offer to sell a security. It does not take into account any investor's particular investment objectives, strategies, tax status or investment horizon. You should consult your tax and financial advisor. All material has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. There is no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the information and State Street shall have no liability for decisions based on such information.
Hypothetical Portfolio Methodology: Sample portfolio returns shown in the above tables are hypothetical and are based on the returns of the underlying market indices in the proportions shown above. For our base case, we assumed that a 60/40 pension which was still in a phase of growing assets would allocate to High Yield and Government bonds for the 40% allocation in fixed income and a mix of developed and emerging market equities for the 60% equity allocation.
The views expressed are the views of Adhiraj Mallik and Orhan Imer through July 31, 2019 and are subject to change based on market and other conditions. This document contains certain statements that may be deemed forward-looking statements. Please note that any such statements are not guarantees of any future performance and actual results or developments may differ materially from those projected. Investing involves risk including the risk of loss of principal.
Actively managed funds do not seek to replicate the performance of a specified index. Equity securities may fluctuate in value in response to the activities of individual companies and general market and economic conditions. Investing in foreign domiciled securities may involve risk of capital loss from unfavorable fluctuation in currency values, withholding taxes, from differences in generally accepted accounting principles or from economic or political instability in other nations.
Investments in emerging or developing markets may be more volatile and less liquid than investing in developed markets and may involve exposure to economic structures that are generally less diverse and mature and to political systems which have less stability than those of more developed countries.
The MSCI World Index, MSCI World ex US and the MSCI US Index are trademarks of MSCI Inc. MSCI indices are the exclusive property of MSCI Inc. (“MSCI”). MSCI and the MSCI index names are service mark(s) of MSCI or its affiliates and have been licensed for use for certain purposes by State Street Global Advisors (“SSGA”). The financial securities referred to herein are not sponsored, endorsed, or promoted by MSCI, and MSCI bears no liability with respect to any such financial securities. No purchaser, seller or holder of this product, or any other person or entity, should use or refer to any MSCI trade name, trademark or service mark to sponsor, endorse, market or promote this product without first contacting MSCI to determine whether MSCI’s permission is required. Under no circumstances may any person or entity claim any affiliation with MSCI without the prior written permission of MSCI.
For use in EMEA:
The information contained in this communication is not a research recommendation or ‘investment research’ and is classified as a ‘Marketing Communication’ in accordance with the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (2014/65/EU) or applicable Swiss regulation. This means that this marketing communication (a) has not been prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research (b) is not subject to any prohibition on dealing ahead of the dissemination of investment research.
All the index performance results referred to are provided exclusively for comparison purposes only. It should not be assumed that they represent the performance of any particular investment.
The trademarks and service marks referenced herein are the property of their respective owners. Third party data providers make no warranties or representations of any kind relating to the accuracy, completeness or timeliness of the data and have no liability for damages of any kind relating to the use of such data.
The whole or any part of this work may not be reproduced, copied or transmitted or any of its contents disclosed to third parties without SSGA’s express written consent.
© 2019 State Street Corporation.
All Rights Reserved.
Exp. Date: 08/31/2020